Are mantle plumes adiabatic?

Ctirad Matyska & David A. Yuen


The issue concerning the state of adiabaticity of mantle plumes has been examined in a cartesian 2-D box with an aspect-ratio of six. We have investigated in the quasi steady-state regime high Rayleigh number convection with both depth-dependent viscosity and thermal expansivity for both the Boussinesq and the extended Boussinesq approximations. We have also assessed the influence of various forms of thermal conductivity and internal heating. We have generalized the classical Bullen's parameter equation from one-dimension to multi-dimensions. For assessing the local state of adiabaticity inside plumes and in their surroundings, we have extracted from the local geotherms and the local thermodynamic properties the corresponding Bullen's parameter profiles and the 2-D maps portraying the state of adiabaticity in the mantle. Histograms characterizing the frequency of adiabaticity are also employed for quantification purposes. In general, superadiabatic thermal gradients are found inside the thick plume limbs and sometimes along the central part of the plume. The centers of plume heads are subadiabatic or nearly adiabatic, but the edges of the plume heads are strongly subadiabatic. Alternating strips of subadiabaticity and adiabaticity are found in the downwellings. The ambient mantle outside the plumes is generally adiabatic and is sometimes perforated with islands of marked deviations from adiabaticity.

Whole paper (PDF)

The paper is available in PDF (1 MB).
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 189 (2001), 165-176.